
Mauricio Pochettino has barely started at Manchester United, and he is already being told who to make an example of. On talkSPORT, Troy Deeney said the new manager should send a message to the dressing room by dropping a long-serving regular, and named Diogo Dalot. Earlier in the week, Gary Neville had made the opposite case.
Crook starts with Mbeumo
The discussion began with Bryan Mbeumo, who posted himself playing the new GTA VI at its midnight release, the night before Pochettino arrived. Alex Crook was unimpressed. “How old is he, 15? Why is he letting people know about it?” Crook said, as reported by Football365. “There’s your example, if you’re Mauricio Pochettino, don’t put him in the squad.”
Deeney agreed that the post sent the wrong message (“you can’t be making those things public”), but argued that a senior player in the dressing room would handle it differently: by pushing Mbeumo hard in training and making him prove himself.
Deeney: drop someone who has been part of the “rot”
Deeney’s main point was about who should take the hit. He considered Andrey Santos, then dismissed him as the easy option: “Maybe it’s [Andrey] Santos as a bit of a, ‘You’re not up to scratch, you’re not in the squad’, and just let people know that he’s laying a marker down. I think that would be a little bit too easy, a low-hanging fruit.”
Instead, he wants a bigger name. “I’d love to see it with a… I don’t know, a Dalot. Just say, ‘You know what? I don’t want you around the team,'” Deeney said. “He has to lay a marker down to one of these players that have been playing week in, week out for the last four to five years, that have been part of this ever-growing rot and mould that’s been coming in the club. And say, ‘No, no more,’ and it has to send a shockwave to the rest of the team.”
The logic is familiar from other rebuilds: a new manager drops someone established early, and everyone else gets the message. Leaving out a young player or a recent signing tells the squad very little. Leaving out someone who has played through several failed regimes tells them nobody is safe.
Neville: “I would get rid of a few before Dalot”
Neville, speaking on Stick to United before Deeney’s comments, had already defended Dalot against exactly this kind of argument. “Do I think Dalot is Denis Irwin? No,” he said, as reported by Goal. “Denis Irwin is the greatest full-back Manchester United have ever had, I shouldn’t be mentioning him in the same breath, but I would get rid of a few before Dalot.”
His defence was not that Dalot is outstanding. “He’s not an amazing player, let’s be clear. He never shirks anything. I think if he was in a decent back four, he’d be all right. But he’s got a shocking back four alongside him.” Neville pointed out that Dalot had been moved to the left and played as a left wing-back under Ruben Amorim without complaint, and said he would move on Noussair Mazraoui, Matthijs de Ligt and Lisandro Martinez first, as Pundit Feed reported in Neville’s defence of Dalot as “such an easy target”.
Two different questions
The two former players are really answering different questions. Neville is asking who should leave if United rebuild the squad, and says Dalot’s willingness and availability put him behind players who are injured or out of form. Deeney is asking who to drop to change the culture, and for him Dalot’s long run in the team is exactly the reason.
Both arguments have weaknesses. Dropping a player who, by Neville’s account, always volunteers to play out of position could look like punishing the wrong man. But Neville’s view that the squad is fine apart from a few sales does not fit a team that has won only one of its first ten league games.
Santos was the subject of another pundit attack this week, when Paul Ince questioned his £50m fee. Pochettino’s first team sheet at Anfield on Sunday will show which advice, if any, he has taken.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
