
Mauricio Pochettino’s first match as Manchester United manager could hardly be more loaded: Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday, with United in the relegation zone and Liverpool fourth. Two former Premier League players looked at the same fixture this week and came to very different conclusions about who is under pressure.
Redknapp: Anfield is a burden for Liverpool too
Jamie Redknapp, who captained Liverpool, argued on The Overlap Daily that the fixture is less straightforward for the home side than the table suggests. United’s recent record at Anfield, he said, cuts both ways. “Well, actually, I think in a way there’s a little bit of pressure [on United] because they’ve done well in this fixture previously,” he said, as reported by the Liverpool Echo.
His bigger point was about Liverpool. “But for Liverpool, it just ramps up the pressure on them, because their home record hasn’t been good this year,” Redknapp said. He pointed to home defeats by Manchester City and Arsenal and added: “They didn’t have a recognised shot on target against Arsenal. Will Poch be looking at this one and thinking: ‘Got a real chance here’.”
Redknapp did leave the other door open. “Or will he be thinking: ‘Oh my God, look how average these players are, how on earth am I going to pick a team?'”
Sutton: “the only question is how many”
Chris Sutton has no such doubts. In his weekly predictions column for BBC Sport, he went for a 4-0 Liverpool win and was blunt about the state of the United defence. “My worry for United is that they have one of the worst back fours in the Premier League,” Sutton wrote. “Their defensive record is something Pochettino will try to address but, whoever he picks, they are just not very good.”
He did not dismiss United’s recent Anfield results, acknowledging two draws and a win in their past three visits, but still saw only one outcome. “Liverpool are going to win. The only question is how many they will score,” he said, before drawing a pointed comparison with Michael Carrick’s start: “Carrick began by beating Manchester City and Arsenal in his first two games in January. Pochettino might start by being on the wrong end of a pummelling.”
Sutton also had advice for the new manager about his captain, suggesting Pochettino would be wise to put an arm around Bruno Fernandes “to get the old sulker onside”, because United need the player who drove their numbers last season.
Where they actually agree
Strip away the scorelines and the two views overlap more than they first appear. Both accept that Liverpool are not yet a finished side under Andoni Iraola. Sutton said it “feels like Iraola is not quite sure what his best midfield is”, while Redknapp’s whole case rests on Liverpool’s patchy home form. Where they differ is on whether that matters against this United team.
Redknapp’s argument is essentially psychological: a side expected to win, at home, against a manager with nothing to lose, can tighten up. Sutton’s is structural: whatever Liverpool’s flaws, United’s defence is bad enough that it will not matter. The midfield question at Liverpool has been running for weeks, and Danny Murphy put it down to tactics earlier this week.
The history offers some support for Redknapp. United’s recent Anfield record is one that Jamie Carragher has also flagged, and Liverpool start the weekend ten points clear of a United side that has won once all season. That gap is the strongest evidence for Sutton’s prediction; the recent head-to-head is the strongest evidence against it.
Pochettino will have had only a few days on the training ground before kick-off at 16:30 on Sunday. If Sutton is right, his reign starts with a hiding. If Redknapp is right, Anfield’s expectations could be what gives United a way in.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
