Gary Neville has rarely been accused of going easy on Manchester United’s defenders this autumn, which is what makes his latest intervention interesting. Asked about Diogo Dalot, the full-back who has become a lightning rod for supporters’ frustration, Neville mounted a defence of the Portuguese and pointed the finger at three more expensive team-mates instead.
Speaking on The United Stand, Neville said he would move Noussair Mazraoui, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt on before Dalot, as reported by Football365. “I would be getting rid of Mazraoui, well gone, before him. I would be getting rid of Martinez well before him. I would be getting rid of De Ligt gone before him,” he said.
“He’s got a shocking back four alongside him”
Neville was careful not to oversell the player he was defending. “Do I think Dalot is Dennis Irwin? No. Let’s be really clear,” he said, before adding that Irwin is “the greatest full-back that Man Utd have ever had”. He conceded that Dalot is “not an amazing player” and that “positionally he’s not great”.
His argument rests on context. Dalot is a right-back who has been asked to play on the left, and Neville, a right-back himself, said he would have refused the same request: “Not a chance. What are you putting me there for?” Dalot, by contrast, is “literally sticking his hand up and saying, ‘Go on, I’ll play there. I’ll do anything for the team’.”
“I never see him shirk anything,” Neville said. “I actually think, to be fair, if he was in a decent back four, he would be all right. I actually do. But he’s got a shocking back four alongside him.” He also said he was “really surprised” that Dalot was booed at Old Trafford last week, and called him “such an easy target”.
The case against the other three
The sharpest words were reserved for De Ligt. “He has got one big problem: he doesn’t play football,” Neville said, arguing that an injury-prone player should not rank above one “who has played every single week and is throwing his hand up”. His verdict was blunt: “De Ligt has to go. I mean, seriously.” On Martinez, he went further still: “Martinez 100%, 100%,100%.”
The money involved sharpens the point. De Ligt and Mazraoui arrived together from Bayern Munich in the summer of 2024 for a combined £60m, while Martinez joined from Ajax in 2022 for £57m. Dalot, the cheapest and least glamorous of the four, is the one being jeered.
The counter-view
The supporters booing Dalot are not short of evidence either. United’s defence has been the weakest part of a side that was in the relegation zone when Michael Carrick was sacked last week, and the man on the left of it is the most visible target when things go wrong. Neville’s own caveats (“He could be better on the ball. He could be better at everything he does”) are close to what his critics say.
There is also a consistency question. Only last week Neville said Mauricio Pochettino needs new defenders immediately, and earlier in the month he warned that United’s defenders could get them relegated. His Dalot defence does not contradict that: it is an argument about who should be first out of the door, not about whether the defence is good enough.
What it means for Pochettino
The underlying point is about reliability. Neville’s ranking places availability and attitude above reputation and fee, which is a recognisable template for a new head coach trying to rebuild a dressing room. Whether Pochettino agrees will become clearer in January, when United’s first window under the Argentine opens.
For now, Neville has given Dalot the kind of backing he has not had from the stands. “I just think he is such an easy target, Dalot, I honestly do,” he said. The next few matches will show whether the crowd comes round to that view, or whether the full-back’s best defence remains a better back four around him.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
