Football • Pundits

Carragher says Pochettino has “a big reputation, but not enough on his CV”; Wes Brown backs him to bring consistency

Before his first game at Anfield, Jamie Carragher questions Mauricio Pochettino’s record in big matches. Wes Brown and Alan Shearer are more patient.

Jamie Carragher at Anfield
Photo: IMAGO / APL

Mauricio Pochettino’s first match as Manchester United manager could hardly be tougher: Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday afternoon, with United in the relegation zone after the worst start to a Premier League season in their history. Before a ball has been kicked, Jamie Carragher has questioned the CV that got him the job.

In his Telegraph column, Carragher argued that Pochettino’s reputation runs ahead of his record. “The Argentine returns to England with a big reputation, but not enough on his CV to back up glowing testimonials,” he wrote, as reported by the Mirror. “This must be one of his motivating factors – the chance to end any sniping and justify the claims of those who are adamant he is one of the most talented coaches of his generation.”

The “recurring issue”

Carragher’s main criticism is about big games. “A recurring issue with Pochettino, which continued with the US team, is an inability to get over the line in the most consequential, winnable matches, resulting in a lack of big trophies,” he wrote. He pointed to the United States losing to Panama in the 2025 Concacaf Nations League semi-final and to Mexico in that summer’s Gold Cup final.

He went back further, to Tottenham. According to Liverpool.com’s report of the column, Carragher wrote: “Whenever Spurs [under Pochettino] came up against Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal and United in knockout football, they could not get the job done.” He added that Spurs finished third in 2016, the season they looked best placed to stop Leicester’s title win.

The Anfield numbers will not help. Pochettino has three wins in 19 meetings with Liverpool as a manager, with five draws and 11 defeats.

Carragher was not wholly negative. He said the appointment could suit both sides precisely because it came about by accident: “The most successful relationships are often built on good timing. If United and Pochettino thrive together, a mutually beneficial alliance born out of circumstance rather than grand design might finally bring stability to Old Trafford.” He also noted that United had passed over Pochettino more than once before.

The case for Pochettino

Other former players are more positive. Wes Brown, the former United defender, told Metro on Thursday that he believes in the appointment. “Poch is very experienced, and he has his own style of play, but it’s all about consistency,” he said, arguing that the job is to make the players believe they are good enough “week in, week out”. Brown even thinks Europe is still possible this season: “There’s still a chance of getting into Europe, 100 per cent.”

That is a bold claim for a side with one league win from ten games. But it rests on the case Pochettino’s supporters always make: he improves players and builds teams that run hard for him, and those qualities matter more to a struggling squad than a trophy cabinet.

Alan Shearer sits between the two. In his Metro predictions column on Friday, he backed Pochettino to turn United round, with a warning: “I think he will eventually, but it will take longer than people think.” For Sunday, he added, “I’ve got no faith defensively in Manchester United,” and backed Liverpool to be too strong.

Who has the stronger argument?

Carragher’s point is hard to argue with on the evidence: Pochettino’s teams have often come up short in the biggest matches. The counter-argument is that United do not need a trophy specialist right now. They need someone to rebuild confidence and organisation in a squad near the bottom of the table, which is exactly the work Pochettino is best known for.

Sunday at Anfield will not settle the debate, but it will be the first evidence. Pundit Feed has already looked at Carragher’s warning about United’s record at Anfield, and at Chris Sutton’s prediction of a heavy defeat. If Pochettino gets a result at the ground where his record is worst, Carragher’s column will look harsh. If he loses heavily, it will be quoted all week.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!