
Mauricio Pochettino has inherited a midfield that cost Manchester United £150m last summer, and the pundits cannot agree on what it is worth. Paul Ince calls Andrey Santos “£50m wasted”; Gary Neville thinks the new manager “might get something out of him”.
Santos arrived from Chelsea for £50m alongside Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba. After an encouraging pre-season he started only four of United’s first ten Premier League matches under Michael Carrick, whose sacking left Pochettino with a side in the relegation zone and the January window as his first chance to reshape it.
Ince: “That’s £50m wasted”
Ince, who won two Premier League titles in United’s midfield, does not see Santos as the answer. “Why did they spend £50m on Santos?” he told The Sun, as reported by Metro. “That’s £50m wasted. They could have put that into the defence or bought a striker.”
He would rather see a player already at the club given the minutes. “They have [Kobbie] Mainoo, who needs to develop. He needs to be playing, not Santos,” he said. Nor was he convinced by the other summer arrivals: “Tielemans, again, fantastic at Villa but it’s a different conversation when you come to United. Baleba didn’t play a lot last year. He comes in for £70m, plays a couple of games and he’s injured again.”
Ince’s wider complaint is about physicality. “The game’s changing. It’s not all pass, pass, pass now. You’ve got to win your duels,” he said, recalling Pep Guardiola’s post-match laments about duels and tackles. “The game’s more physical, more powerful.”
And he ended on the club as a whole. “What you’ve got is players playing for Manchester United, not Manchester United players,” he said. “That’s a big difference. Who’s a Manchester United player out there? [Declan] Rice, Jude Bellingham. They are who you should be going for. Since Sir Alex Ferguson left it’s been a complete disaster. Would every player in the world want to come to United? They don’t, because it’s a basket case there, a shambles.”
Neville: “He might get something out of him”
Neville, running through the squad on the Stick to United podcast this week, reached a more patient verdict on the same midfield. “I’d keep Bruno [Fernandes], I’d keep Kobbie [Mainoo], I’d keep [Youri] Tielemans, [Mason] Mount would have to go,” he said, in comments carried by Yahoo Sports.
On Santos he gave Pochettino the benefit of the doubt. “[Andrey] Santos – Mauricio may like him because he’s young, quite mobile, he’s aggressive, he might get something out of him. Him and [Carlos] Baleba will be in that middle bit,” he said.
Neville’s timescale is the key difference. He sees the rebuild happening in waves, with Baleba and Santos judged later: “And then the year after you’d be looking at Shaw, Maguire, [Diogo] Dalot, Bruno, that’s your second wave and maybe then you’ve made your mind up on Baleba and Santos.” His conclusion was sobering: “But the earliest Mauricio Pochettino can unravel this squad is two seasons if he does well. It could take three.” The same discussion produced his defence of Diogo Dalot and his list of defenders to sell.
Two readings of one signing
The pair agree on more than it first appears. Both want Mainoo playing, both see the squad as a long project, and Neville has already argued that only Mainoo looks good enough in United’s midfield as it stands.
Where they part is on whether the summer money is already lost. Ince judges Santos on the fee and four starts; Neville judges him on attributes, youth, mobility and aggression, that a new coach might work with. Ince’s emphasis on duels arguably points the same way: an aggressive young midfielder is the kind of player who should suit the more physical game he describes.
For a player who started fewer than half of United’s league games under the previous manager, Pochettino’s first weeks are effectively a fresh trial. If Santos plays and wins his battles, Neville’s patience will look wise. If Mainoo is preferred and Santos stays on the fringes, Ince’s “£50m wasted” will be quoted back at the club for a long time.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
