Football • Pundits

Shearer thinks Chelsea will “just have enough” for Leeds; Joe Hart says Farke’s side “can go there and really do something”

Leeds have not won at Stamford Bridge since 1999. Alan Shearer narrowly backs Chelsea, Joe Hart senses “a quiet belief” at Leeds, and Chris Sutton sits on the fence.

Alan Shearer at St James’ Park
Photo: IMAGO / Sportimage

Leeds United have not won at Stamford Bridge since December 1999, when Stephen McPhail scored twice in a 2-0 win. They return to west London on Saturday afternoon (3pm UK) with a better chance than most of their recent visits, and the pundits cannot agree on whether they will take it.

Alan Shearer leans towards Chelsea, but only just. Joe Hart thinks something is building at Leeds. Chris Sutton, writing for BBC Sport on Thursday evening, went for a draw.

Shearer: home advantage should be enough

In his weekly Premier League predictions, Shearer told Metro that Chelsea are hard to read. “I think Leeds will make it tough for Chelsea at Stamford Bridge,” he said. “I think it’ll be a very up and down season for Chelsea. They’ll have a good result one week and a poor result the next, so I think it’s very difficult to predict their scoreline.”

He was not convinced by Chelsea’s defending either, but he still landed on a home win: “Just again, because they’re at home, I think they’ll just have enough to beat Leeds on this occasion.”

It is a cautious pick rather than a confident one. “Just enough” is a long way from backing Chelsea to win comfortably, and Shearer’s description of a team that swings between good and poor results matches their last league outing: a 1-0 defeat at Sunderland before the international break.

Hart: “a quiet belief” at Leeds

Joe Hart is more optimistic about the away side. Speaking on The Overlap Daily on Friday, the former England goalkeeper pointed to the mood around Daniel Farke’s team after Noah Okafor came off the bench to score a late winner against Tottenham at Elland Road.

“They kind of keep threatening don’t they Chelsea, then falling,” Hart said, as reported by MOT Leeds News. “There’s a quiet belief in Leeds United. They’ll be respectful and obviously they’ll have their eye on an incredible Chelsea team with names, but I think with their team dynamic, they can go there and really do something.”

Hart did not go as far as predicting a Leeds win. His point is about direction of travel: Chelsea keep promising and stalling, while Leeds go into the game on the back of that win over Spurs.

Sutton sits in the middle

Sutton’s BBC Sport column, published on Thursday evening, also gives Leeds a chance. He described Chelsea as “lethargic” in the defeat at Sunderland and said that even with Joao Pedro fit, “I still have a feeling Leeds will get something out of this”. His prediction was 1-1.

He also highlighted the defence. Only Arsenal and Brighton have conceded fewer league goals than Leeds this season, and he credited James Trafford, the goalkeeper who left Manchester City for regular football and is now pushing Jordan Pickford for England’s No 1 shirt. Pundit Feed covered that goalkeeping debate when Jermaine Pennant backed Trafford over Pickford.

The counter-argument: history and the cup

The case for Chelsea goes beyond Shearer’s caution. Leeds have been to Stamford Bridge ten times since that 1999 win without winning, and they lost 6-3 there in the Carabao Cup in August. Leeds have also won only once in their last 28 trips to London, against any opponent. Chelsea are fifth, four places above Leeds, although a Leeds win would take them above Xabi Alonso’s side in a crowded table.

That cup game is a warning for anyone backing a tight contest. When Chelsea’s forwards are on form, Leeds can be opened up. Shearer’s worry about Chelsea’s defending, though, cuts the other way: if they concede against a side as organised as Leeds, they may not get a second chance.

What the split tells us

Hart and Sutton mostly agree that this Leeds side is solid enough to frustrate Chelsea. Shearer is backing Chelsea’s quality at home, but with plenty of doubts. None of the three expects an easy afternoon for Alonso.

The same weekend brings Newcastle against Arsenal, where Shearer’s heart and head also pull in different directions, and where Sutton expects Arsenal to win comfortably. By Saturday evening we will know which of these pundits read the weekend best.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!