Football • Pundits

Sutton says Arsenal will “pick off” a “kamikaze” Newcastle; Shearer expects a cool welcome for Guimaraes

Chris Sutton backs Arsenal to win comfortably at St James’ Park and says Mikel Arteta’s side have not even got going yet. Alan Shearer expects Bruno Guimaraes to get a frosty reception on his return.

Mikel Arteta, Arsenal v Everton, 2026
Photo: IMAGO / Every Second Media

Arsenal travel to St James’ Park on Saturday evening with nine wins from ten league games and only five goals conceded. Chris Sutton, who is at the game for BBC Sport, thinks the champions will win it at a canter, and that the real story is how little they have had to do so far.

Sutton’s case: Newcastle have no defined style

In his weekly predictions column, Sutton went for a 2-0 away win and built his case on Newcastle rather than Arsenal. He called it “a huge one for Newcastle boss Matthias Jaissle”, noting that the Magpies have 12 points from ten games, the same return as at the same stage last season, but that the supporters are not yet sold on the new man.

“Some of their unease is because Newcastle don’t seem to have a defined style of play, and can be a bit kamikaze going forward,” Sutton wrote. “Because of that, I just think Arsenal will pick them off, and win comfortably.”

His more striking line was about Mikel Arteta’s side. “The worry for their rivals is that it feels to me Mikel Arteta’s side have not even got going yet, but I still don’t see anyone being close to them.”

That is a bold claim about a team that has won nine of its ten league games, but it fits a theme that has run through the season. Arsenal have been winning through control and defensive solidity rather than overwhelming attacking performances, and the defence has rarely been tested. Sutton’s guest this week, the boxer Lauren Price, an Arsenal fan, went further still with a 4-0 prediction.

The counterpoint: a hostile night for Guimaraes

If there is a case for Newcastle, it is the occasion. Bruno Guimaraes returns to St James’ Park for the first time since his £75m move to Arsenal in the summer, and Alan Shearer does not expect a warm welcome. Speaking on All Out Football on Wednesday, Shearer said: “I don’t think it’ll be as bad as Isak, but I don’t think it’ll be a good reception,” as reported by Arsenal Insider.

Shearer was careful not to condemn the player. “I mean, ultimately Bruno wanted to leave, which is fine,” he said. “But he wanted to leave and he didn’t want to be there any longer, and I get that and understand that, but sometimes fans of your football club, or our football club, don’t understand that.”

Whether a “kamikaze” Newcastle, to use Sutton’s word, can turn noise into chances against a defence that has conceded five league goals in ten games is the question.

Is “not even got going” fair?

Sutton’s line will irritate Newcastle supporters and probably delight Arsenal ones, but it is a reasonable reading of the numbers. A side that has won nine of ten while still being described as below its best is, by definition, a side with a high floor. Shearer has been among those who see Brighton as Arsenal’s main threat, and the centre-back debate around Ezri Konsa has given Arteta a selection problem of the pleasant kind.

The flip side is that Jaissle’s Newcastle have matched last season’s points total at this stage, which is not the record of a side in crisis. Sutton’s argument is less about Newcastle being poor and more about them being open, and against an Arsenal team this efficient, openness tends to be punished.

Kick-off is at 17:30 on Saturday. If Sutton is right, Arsenal extend their near-perfect start before Liverpool and United meet on Sunday. If Newcastle use the Guimaraes subplot to raise the temperature, it will be the first real examination of whether the champions can play their way through a hostile ground.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!