
Michael Carrick has gone, Mauricio Pochettino is in, and on Sunday United play at Anfield. Michael Owen, who played for both clubs, still thinks the way the change was handled says something about Manchester United, and it is not flattering.
“Nothing that the club does in recent times has smacked of class, has it?” Owen told Liverpool.com in an exclusive interview. “It’s just not the club it once was, and I’m sure it will return, but it might take a bit more change before it does.”
How Carrick’s exit unfolded
Carrick was sacked on 12 November and Pochettino was announced the following day. In the days before, reports said United planned to approach Pochettino while Carrick was still in charge, and it later emerged that the club had agreed terms with the Argentine before the change was made. For a club legend who won the 2008 Champions League and several league titles as a player, the way it ended was messy.
Owen does not pretend United had many good options. “I didn’t think it was handled great, but there’s not much that Manchester United have done over the last dozen years that has been handled that amazingly well,” he said.
“In a well-run club, it just doesn’t happen”
His bigger point is about the culture that led to the sacking. Before Carrick went, Lisandro Martinez and Bruno Fernandes both criticised the team publicly, and Owen sees that as a sign of a club where the usual rules have broken down.
“It all filters through from the top, and you look at leading into that, the next biggest thing in the lead-up was two players coming out and being critical of tactics,” he said. “In a well-run club, it just doesn’t happen. Things like that never happen.”
He praised the way Carrick left, saying he “held his head up high with a lot of integrity like you would expect from Michael Carrick”, and suggested Carrick had probably done the club a favour by doing so.
Carrick’s own farewell statement backed that up. “I’ve had the immense privilege of leading Manchester United, the football club that I love,” he said, thanking supporters as “a special, rare breed”. There was no complaint about the timing.
Is there another side?
Owen is far from alone in criticising the club. Alan Shearer called it “an absolute disgrace” last week, as Pundit Feed reported when Shearer and Lineker reacted to the change, and Peter Schmeichel called United’s treatment of Carrick “very disrespectful” on 11 November, in comments we covered at the time.
There is another way to see it, though. Football is ruthless, and a manager whose team is near the bottom of the table rarely gets a gentle exit. From the club’s side, making sure of their preferred replacement before acting reduced the risk of being left without a head coach in the middle of a crisis.
Owen’s argument does not really depend on whether sacking Carrick was right. It is about how the club operates: players criticising tactics in public, a replacement lined up while the manager is still in post, and a club legend left to handle it with dignity. Those are signs of a club that has lost control of its own story, whatever the merits of the decision.
What it means for Pochettino
The new manager inherits all of this. Owen’s comment that “it all filters through from the top” is a reminder that a new head coach cannot fix problems that start in the boardroom. Pochettino’s first task is on the pitch, at the ground where United have often struggled, but his longer-term success will depend on whether the club behaves differently around him.
Owen is sure the old United “will return”. His caveat, that it “might take a bit more change”, suggests he does not think replacing the manager is enough.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
