Football • Pundits

Shearer calls United’s handling of Carrick “an absolute disgrace”; Lineker doubts Pochettino will last 18 months

On The Rest Is Football, Alan Shearer said Carrick’s sacking was fair but the process lacked class. Gary Lineker predicted Pochettino will become the next scapegoat for problems “above the coach”.

Manchester United’s new head coach has not yet taken a training session, and the two leading voices on The Rest Is Football have already reached a verdict on the club that hired him. Alan Shearer called the way Michael Carrick was removed “an absolute disgrace”, while Gary Lineker said he would be surprised if Mauricio Pochettino is still in the job in 18 months.

Shearer: the decision was fair, the process was not

Shearer was clear that he had no quarrel with the sacking itself. Carrick was dismissed on Thursday after an eight-game winless Premier League run that left United in the relegation zone. “I don’t think you’re going to have any complaints (over Carrick’s exit) because of the results,” he said on the podcast, as reported by UtdReport. “You know when you’re a coach or a manager, if you don’t win games, ultimately you’re going to get sacked. But I think it is an absolute disgrace how it unfolded.”

His objection was to the days in between, when Carrick continued to take training while the club’s leadership held talks about his replacement. “How he (Carrick) had to read about it every single day for the last 10 days about who they (INEOS) were going to meet, where they’re going to meet them, who they’re going to appoint,” Shearer said. “I just think it was so lacking in class,” he continued. “So unprofessional, and it should not have happened and been played out that way for anyone, let alone anyone who had represented United as well as Carrick has done over the years.”

Lineker: “rinse and repeat”

Lineker looked forward rather than back, and his prediction was bleak. “I see Pochettino going in there, and I think they’ll probably get off to a reasonable start, and they’ll do okay for a while,” he said, in comments reported by Football365. “He’ll go on there, and then he’ll be disappointed with the way things occur in the future, and if he’s still there in 18 months, I’ll be surprised.”

His reasoning was about the structure above the dugout rather than the coach in it. “Because again and again, it’s rinse and repeat; the scapegoat is always the coach, and you can see that. And I think the real problems are above the coach,” he said. “These guys are all good coaches. You look at some of the names they’ve had in the last 10 years. What’s that, 12 coaches now who have gone since Alex Ferguson? And they all leave and they say the club’s a mess.”

Lineker also argued that United “didn’t back Carrick properly in the summer”, and that the ownership has not improved under Sir Jim Ratcliffe: “Obviously, there have been years and years of complaints and demonstrations against the Glazers, and obviously Ratcliffe hasn’t made any difference. If anything, they’re worse now.”

Two complaints, one target

The two arguments fit together. Shearer’s point is about how United treat their coaches on the way out; Lineker’s is that the same treatment awaits the next one. Both put the responsibility on the people making the decisions rather than on the head coach, which echoes Gary Neville’s view earlier this month that sacking Carrick would not fix United.

There is a counter-case, and Lineker half-made it himself. Pochettino is a proven coach with Premier League experience at Tottenham and Chelsea, and a reasonable start is exactly what United need. Pochettino himself framed the move as an opportunity too big to refuse. “I never said I wanted to go back [to the Premier League] but they know there aren’t too many opportunities that happen in your career like Manchester United. When it arrives, it’s difficult to turn down,” he said on Friday.

Carrick’s own record adds a complication to the blame-the-board view. He lifted United to third place and Champions League qualification last season before the collapse this autumn. Lineker praised that spell, but it also shows how quickly things can turn at Old Trafford, for coaches and pundits’ predictions alike.

Shearer is not the first to criticise the handling of Carrick’s exit: Peter Schmeichel called it very disrespectful earlier in the week.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!