Football • Pundits

Murphy says Liverpool’s midfield problem is “a tactical thing”; Carragher wants Iraola to buy in January

Danny Murphy says Liverpool’s open midfield needs tactical discipline, not new signings. Jamie Carragher says Andoni Iraola should get the player he wants in January.

Liverpool’s midfield has been the talk of their autumn, and two former Anfield players disagree on the fix. Danny Murphy says the problem is “a tactical thing”, not a shortage of players; Jamie Carragher wants Andoni Iraola to go and buy the player he needs in January.

Iraola replaced the dismissed Arne Slot in June and has four senior signings, costing more than £200m combined, behind him. Liverpool are fourth, but have taken only five points from five home league games, and Manchester United arrive at Anfield on Sunday.

Murphy: “That’s not a personnel thing”

Murphy was asked about two midfielders linked with Liverpool, Bournemouth’s Alex Scott and Crystal Palace’s Adam Wharton, and was not convinced by either. “I don’t see Alex Scott as a holding midfielder and Adam Wharton, who is more of a traditional holding midfielder, isn’t playing particularly well at the moment,” he told PariuriX.com, as reported by Liverpool.com.

On Scott, who played under Iraola at Bournemouth, he questioned whether the athleticism is there for the role. “He’s a lovely footballer who I admire but I don’t think he has the athleticism to play that role in a team that wants to go forward and attack because you’ve got to cover so much ground,” he said.

His bigger point is that signings are not the priority. “I think at the moment, if you prioritize what you need, it’s not so much about personnel than it is about tactical shifts,” Murphy said. He wants one of the existing midfielders, “whether it be Nyoni, or Mac Allister or [Ryan] Gravenberch”, to be “more disciplined”, adding: “It feels at the moment that the midfield has got free license to go and do whatever to win games. Unfortunately that doesn’t make you compact.”

His model is the league leaders. “The best example, if you watch Arsenal, all their midfielders, even Odegaard drops back in. Their shape is so good. Yes it’s not great on the eye and at times they get criticized, but it’s really hard to play against them.”

Murphy also acknowledged the disruption Iraola has faced, with injuries to Dominik Szoboszlai and Gravenberch and Bradley Barcola “still learning on the job”. His conclusion: “At the moment it just feels like whoever plays in the midfield, it’s wide open. And that’s not a personnel thing, that’s a tactical thing.”

Carragher: “Every transfer window is very important”

Carragher, speaking earlier this week on The Overlap Fan Debate, sees the January window differently. “I look at this January window for Andoni Iraola and think he needs to go and get the player he wants for the certain position rather than waiting for the summer,” he said, in comments carried by Yahoo Sports.

Iraola’s contract is part of his reasoning. “He’s only signed a two-year contract, and that was of his own accord which is fine, but that means every transfer window is very important,” Carragher said. “The areas on the pitch for Liverpool that still stand out for are the full-back areas. If there’s a left-back, they’ve got to go and do it in January. Or a midfield player, a certain type of midfield player.”

He also framed Sunday as a test for the manager. “I think he’s made a good start. The one thing lacking is a stellar performance,” he said, noting that Liverpool lost their home games against Manchester City and Arsenal despite performing well in them.

Coaching or recruitment?

The two positions are less opposed than the headlines suggest. Both accept that Liverpool are too open; Carragher even specifies “a certain type of midfield player”, which sounds like the disciplined holder Murphy describes. The difference is whether Iraola can create that profile from Nyoni, Mac Allister and Gravenberch, or must buy it.

Murphy’s case rests on Arsenal’s example of what shape alone can do. Carragher’s rests on time: a coach on a two-year deal cannot wait long for a tactical fix to take hold. Murphy has been critical of Liverpool’s defence before, saying Milos Kerkez “lacks composure”, so his reluctance to spend is not a blanket defence of the squad.

Sunday offers the first evidence. A compact, controlled performance against United would support Murphy’s view that the tools are already there. Another open game at Anfield would strengthen Carragher’s call for January reinforcements, and United, as Carragher himself has warned, have a decent record at Anfield.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!