
The fastest court the ATP Finals has seen since moving to Turin has found its loudest critics in two Italian greats. Adriano Panatta calls it “ice” and wants to know who chose the speed; Paolo Bertolucci says the sport is being killed. Daniil Medvedev, one of the players actually on it, thinks indoor tennis should be exactly this quick.
“I’d like to know who the idiot is”
The numbers behind the row come from the journalist José Morgado, who put the Court Pace Index in Turin this year at 45.8, the fastest since the event moved to the city in 2021. Analyst Matthew Willis added that the ball was in play for only 10 minutes during Alexander Zverev’s win over Ben Shelton on Tuesday, and that half the points ended in a single shot.
Panatta, a former French Open champion, was scathing on the Italian podcast La Telefonata, in comments reported by Tennis365 via Fanpage. He started with the presentation: “Tennis is a detail; that is, it’s all spectacle, disco, psychedelic lights. It’s all there. It’s absolutely vulgar, really.”
Then he turned to the court. “You know what the big problem is? That, in my opinion, they made a mess with the carpet where they set it up, etc. It’s ice,” he said. “Are you playing tennis? Yesterday I saw [Flavio] Cobolli; was it tennis? In my opinion, they’re truly scientists. I’d like to know who the idiot is who decides the speed. A name, you who are there, that everyone knows. It’s the ATP. Who the hell does these things?”
Bertolucci: “They’re killing everything”
Paolo Bertolucci, a former world No 12, went further and predicted what the trend would do to the kind of player who succeeds. “I said they’re killing everything. There’s a decline now. Soon, only those two meters tall, who serve hard, who have a half-hearted groundstroke and that’s it, will be needed,” he said.
“What are they doing? Clay pigeon shooting? There’s no rallies, nothing fun. If they don’t get their act together, it’s a disaster.”
Their objection is about spectacle as much as speed: short points, few rallies and an indoor show that, for Panatta, has pushed the tennis into the background.
Medvedev: “Indoor hard courts should be fast”
None of the players seems to be complaining, and Medvedev, who lost 6-2, 6-4 to Carlos Alcaraz on Wednesday, made the opposite case. After the match he argued that variety between surfaces is good for the sport, and that fast indoor courts are part of that variety.
“The more different surfaces we have, the better it is. Everyone likes different courts and different balls. Even I sometimes complain when hard courts are too slow, but the reality is that the more different courts we have, the better,” he said, as quoted by Tennis Up To Date. “The only thing I think is that indoor hard courts shouldn’t be slow. I think indoor hard courts should be fast, as they have been for years. They should be a bit like here, or perhaps like Paris.”
He added that the speed had not saved him against the world No 3. “I still think the reality is that the faster the surface, the easier it is and the more chances you have to beat Carlos,” he said. “But look, he wins a lot of matches, and it doesn’t matter which surface. He’s basically won all four Grand Slams, so it doesn’t matter whether it’s slow or fast.”
A season of the opposite complaint
The irony is that most of this year’s grumbling has gone the other way. Players spent the autumn complaining that conditions were too slow, from Zverev’s frustration with the balls and court in Vienna to Jack Draper’s warning about slower courts and slower balls. Taylor Fritz has also argued that the real fix is better balls.
Turin is the one big event that has gone fast, and the reaction shows how hard the balance is. To Medvedev it is a welcome contrast with the slower hard courts elsewhere. To Panatta and Bertolucci, ten minutes of ball in play in a match lasting more than an hour and a half is not the tennis they want to watch.
Both sides have a point. A tour where every surface plays the same rewards one style; a final event where half the points end after the serve rewards another. The question for the ATP is whether Turin’s speed is a deliberate counterweight or an accident of the carpet, and Panatta, for one, would like a name.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
