Football • Pundits

Hamann wants compensation and “a hefty points deduction” if Man City’s appeal fails; Mills says a “slap on the wrist” would be “an absolute farce”

Didi Hamann says City should compensate other clubs and lose points if their appeal fails. Danny Mills goes further and wants them punished for “seven seasons”.

Didi Hamann working as a TV pundit at a DFB Cup semi-final in Stuttgart, April 2026
Photo: IMAGO / Sven Simon

Manchester City’s appeal has not yet been heard, but the debate about what should happen if it fails is already in full swing. Didi Hamann wants City to compensate the other clubs and lose a “hefty” number of points; Danny Mills says anything resembling “a slap on the wrist” would be “an absolute farce”.

City have been found guilty on 114 of 115 charges of breaching the Premier League’s financial regulations between 2009 and 2018. The club continue to insist on their innocence and have appealed. The possible sanctions range from a fine or transfer ban to a points deduction, expulsion or being stripped of titles.

Hamann: compensation, then points

Speaking to GOAL, Hamann began by admitting how little anyone outside the process really knows. “Everybody’s got an opinion and people pretend to know something,” he said, in comments carried by Football365. “One guy told me the other day they might get off with the charges. Another guy says 70 points deduction. Another guy said the sanctions will be for next season.”

His own view is a two-part punishment. “If the appeal fails, which I think is coming out in the next few weeks, there’s got to be financial compensation to the other clubs and on top a hefty points deduction,” he said.

Hamann also recognised the knock-on problem of a deduction big enough to relegate City. “But then the Championship clubs already mentioned that they don’t want them down there because they take one place of only three that go up,” he said. “So, it’s a decision I wouldn’t like to make. But anything other than financial compensation and a hefty points deduction, I’d be surprised.”

Mills: punish the seasons, not the count

Mills, also speaking to GOAL, took a harder line and compared City’s case with those of Everton and Nottingham Forest. “If it’s a slap on the wrist, it’s an absolute farce,” he said. “Everton were done on one or two charges. [Nottingham] Forest the same. Six points, four points, a couple of charges, and they were open about it. They were honest about it.”

His argument is that the number of charges matters less than the length of time involved. “We’re looking at seven major breaches, aren’t we? I know there are 114 but there are clearly seven or eight seasons where financial doping was massive. And that is the biggest problem,” he said. “I think you’re going to have to look at those seven seasons, eight seasons, and say, ‘well, that’s what they really need to be punished for, seriously’.”

He also wants City’s conduct during the case taken into account. “And then the fact they haven’t helped out, they’ve delayed it as long as possible. You could add a punishment on top for that,” he said, before reaching for an analogy: “You get a speeding fine, you hold your hands up, admit it, you get three points. You go to court, fight it, lose, get six points. It shouldn’t be massively complicated, should it? For me, a punishment for seven seasons would be fitting.”

Where they agree, and where they differ

Both pundits start from the same place: if the verdict stands, a points deduction is unavoidable. The difference is in the scale and the logic. Hamann’s is a practical answer, compensation for the clubs affected plus a deduction, from someone openly uneasy about what relegation would mean for the Championship. Mills frames it as a matter of consistency with Everton and Forest, and treats City’s decision to fight the charges as an aggravating factor rather than a right.

That last point is the most contentious. City are entitled to defend themselves and to appeal, and they maintain they did nothing wrong. Whether contesting the case should add to any punishment is a question for the appeal panel, not for pundits, and Mills’ speeding-fine analogy will strike City supporters as prejudging a process that is still running.

Hamann’s opening line may be the most honest contribution of all: nobody outside the process knows how this ends. The range of guesses he described, from City escaping to a 70-point deduction, shows how wide the uncertainty is. Lawyers are not confident either: Nick Harris reported that only a quarter of them expect City to win the appeal, and Gary Neville has already wondered whether the case is weighing on City’s form.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!