James Trafford’s late saves in Madrid helped England end Spain’s 43-match unbeaten run, and they have reopened the debate over England’s goalkeeper. Jermaine Pennant has picked his side. Speaking on talkSPORT, the former England winger said Trafford is “better than” Jordan Pickford and should be England’s first choice from now on.
Pennant: “There’s a mistake in him”
“I think he’s better than Pickford,” Pennant said, as reported by Football365. “Pickford with England, when he puts on an English shirt, yes, he does great, but you always think there’s a mistake in him.”
He listed the areas he worries about: “You know, whether it’s his kicking, whether it’s the ball at his feet or shot-stopping. He is good, but I just think from today’s performance, Trafford has made a massive statement.”
Pennant imagined how the incumbent might be feeling. “And if you’re Jordan Pickford, you’re thinking, ‘Oh, am I the No. 1 now moving forward?’ Because that was a solid performance from Trafford.” He also defended the 24-year-old over the goals Spain scored: “All the goals that he conceded were not his fault. Nothing he could really do about them at all.”
His conclusion was about the direction of the team as much as the individual. “For me, I just think moving forward now with the young guns, the new era, the new style of play, that I think you may have to start looking at Trafford to be the number one.”
What happened in Madrid
Trafford started both of England’s Nations League games against Spain, sharing duties with Pickford over the international window. In the 3-2 win on Sunday, he barely touched the ball in the first hour as England built a 3-0 lead through Harry Kane, Ezri Konsa and Ben White. After Elliot Anderson’s red card, Spain pulled two back and pressed for an equaliser, and Trafford made six saves, including a double save in the closing stages, to earn the man of the match award on his fifth cap.
Pennant’s criticism of Pickford is sharper than the record suggests. Pickford has 94 caps since his debut in 2017 and has been England’s first choice for almost all of that time, with his kicking usually seen as a strength rather than a weakness.
The counter-view
Not every pundit is ready to make the switch. Paul Robinson, a former England goalkeeper himself, insisted last week that Pickford is still England’s No 1 and that the Trafford debate is one for “down the road”. Roy Keane, speaking before the Spain game, praised Thomas Tuchel’s “smart management” of the two keepers and said there was “not much between” them.
Even after the win, the view that one game settles nothing has support. Trafford’s calmness in possession impressed, but Pickford has years of tournament football behind him, and a strong half-hour against Spain does not erase that.
Tuchel’s call
The interesting part of Pennant’s argument is not the claim that Trafford is better today. It is the idea that Tuchel’s England, with younger players and a different style, might suit a goalkeeper who is more comfortable building play. By picking Trafford for both Spain games, Tuchel has at least shown he wants to find out.
The decision may not come for a while. England’s next fixtures are the Nations League quarter-finals, drawn on Friday, and Tuchel has so far preferred to share the gloves. But on the evidence of Madrid, Trafford has given the manager a real choice, and Pennant has made the case for change in the bluntest terms yet.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
