Two of the biggest contract decisions at Liverpool this season concern the spine of the team: Virgil van Dijk and Alisson Becker are both out of contract at the end of the campaign. Jamie Carragher thinks one of those is close to settled and the other is genuinely open.
Speaking on The Overlap, Carragher said the captain is all but certain to be offered, and to accept, a new deal. “I think Van Dijk would be a cert to stay, I would imagine,” he said, in comments reported by Football365. The goalkeeper, he suggested, is a different matter: “I think that’s certainly one to watch with the goalkeeper.”
Why Carragher sees the two cases differently
Van Dijk is 35, has been at Anfield since 2018 and remains a key figure for Andoni Iraola, with 15 appearances so far this season. Carragher did not set out a detailed argument for his confidence, but the subtext is clear enough: there is no obvious successor at centre-back, and the captain is still first choice.
Alisson is a more complicated case because Liverpool have already planned for life after him. In the summer they agreed a £30m deal with Club Brugge for the 18-year-old goalkeeper Lucca Brughmans, who is spending this season on loan in Belgium before moving to Merseyside next summer.
Carragher said he could “see it from both sort of ways”. Liverpool might ask whether they need another goalkeeper, or whether Alisson’s injuries argue for change, or they might “kick the can down the road for 12 months” and wait for their long-term target. “All clubs plan for years ahead,” he said.
The player’s own position
The obvious counterweight to Carragher’s certainty is Van Dijk himself, who has been noticeably non-committal. Earlier this month he said: “Let’s see what the season brings. I’ve had an amazing time already so far. If that will be extended, that’s the case. If not, then I will go somewhere else.”
He also stressed that there was “nothing to report at the moment”, that he was “not in any panic whatsoever”, and that he had been “struggling with a little niggle the past couple of weeks”. That is not the language of a player who has already agreed terms, although it is also not the language of someone who is pushing for the exit.
So the gap between pundit and player is mostly one of tone. Carragher is reading the club’s needs and the captain’s status; Van Dijk is keeping his options open in public, which is standard practice for a player in the final months of a contract.
The goalkeeping question is the real one
If Carragher is right about Van Dijk, Alisson’s situation becomes the more consequential call. The Brughmans deal means Liverpool have a successor lined up, but an 18-year-old arriving from the Belgian league is a very different proposition from a goalkeeper of Alisson’s experience. Letting Alisson leave would effectively commit Liverpool to a young keeper, or to another signing to bridge the gap.
Carragher’s “kick the can” option, a short extension that buys a year, is the compromise many clubs reach in that position. It keeps an elite keeper in place while the successor develops, at the cost of putting off a decision rather than making it.
The timing matters, too. Liverpool’s next big test is the visit of Manchester United to Anfield, a game Carragher has already warned will be no formality. Contract talk will not decide that match, but a squad in which the captain and the goalkeeper are both entering the final months of their deals is a storyline that will follow Iraola all season.
For now, Carragher’s view is a simple one: the captain stays, and the goalkeeper is the decision to watch.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
