Football • Pundits

Only a quarter of lawyers think Man City will win their appeal, says Nick Harris; Haaland answers with his youth-team CV

Football finance journalist Nick Harris says most lawyers he has spoken to expect City to lose their appeal, due to be heard in mid-December. Erling Haaland’s response to the question was a list of his youth teams.

Manchester City’s appeal against the independent commission’s verdict is expected to be heard in mid-December, and one of the most prominent voices reporting on the case has offered a blunt assessment of the club’s chances. Nick Harris, the football finance journalist, says that only around a quarter of the lawyers he has spoken to expect City to win, and fewer still think they will win on the points that matter.

Harris: “ie: will still lose”

Harris set out his reading on X over the weekend. “From multiple lawyers I’ve spoken to, perhaps 25% think City will win appeal or parts of appeal but fewer think City will win substantive points. ie: will still lose,” he wrote, as reported by Football365. He then added a caveat of his own, comparing those odds with Donald Trump’s chances on the morning of the 2016 US presidential election: low, but not low enough to rule anything out.

It is a useful corrective in both directions. City supporters who expect the verdict to be overturned are reminded that legal opinion leans heavily the other way. Rivals who assume the matter is settled are reminded that a one-in-four chance is not nothing.

The timetable

According to the Financial Times, the appeal is set to go ahead in mid-December and could run for a number of days. A verdict is expected in the new year, with any decision on sanctions to follow. Even then, it is not clear when sanctions would take effect, and they would themselves be open to appeal, which means the uncertainty could stretch beyond the end of the season in May.

The commission found City in breach of Premier League financial rules over a nine-season period, criticising what it called “sham” sponsorship contracts. City deny wrongdoing and say they have evidence to prove their innocence, in the form of documents they argue show that sponsorship funds came from the Abu Dhabi government rather than from the club’s owners. In September, the club said it had “diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis the Premier League board and executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair minded regulator, free from partisan influence”.

Haaland’s answer

Erling Haaland, asked about “the situation” after scoring and assisting in Norway’s 3-1 Nations League win over Wales, chose a pointed history lesson instead. “The investigation covered 2009 to 2018. In 2009, I played for Bryne U9s,” he told the Norwegian broadcaster TV2, as quoted by the Mirror, before working his way up through the age groups to his Molde days. He also made clear he is very happy at the club.

It was a deft way of underlining his own distance from the period under investigation. But it also sidesteps the question supporters and rivals are asking, which is what happens to the club, and to the titles won in that period, if the appeal fails.

The pundits’ “stain”

That question has hung over City’s season since the verdict. Speaking after City’s win at Anfield on 11 October, Gary Neville warned that City fans did not yet “recognise right now the stain, the stigma and the damage this is going to do to them”, while Jamie Carragher argued: “We need a resolution as soon as possible.” Both were speaking on Sky Sports.

More recently, Neville suggested the case could be dragging City’s form down. The timetable now reported gives that theory a long runway. If the appeal is heard in December and judged in the new year, City will play most of the season, and possibly all of it, without knowing what their results will ultimately be worth.

Harris’s numbers do not decide anything. But they are the clearest signal yet of where informed legal opinion sits, and they suggest that the “resolution” Carragher asked for may not be the one City want.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!