Alexander Zverev opens his ATP Finals campaign in Turin today against Rafael Jodar as the year-end world No. 1, and still as the most debated No. 1 in years. Patrick Mouratoglou has now told the critics to back off, Flavio Cobolli agrees he has earned it, and Toni Nadal is not quite ready to call him the best player in the world.
Mouratoglou: “Leave Zverev alone”
Mouratoglou, Serena Williams’ former coach, used Instagram to answer the argument that has followed Zverev since he climbed to the top after Vienna: that Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz were injured, and that he beat very few top-10 players on the way. His reply, reported by The Tennis Gazette, was blunt: “Leave Zverev alone, he deserves to be number one.”
His case rests on the simplest principle in the rankings. “The guy who has the most points is number one in the world. Fair. He’s probably the guy who’s working the most,” Mouratoglou said. “There were 128 players at every Grand Slam. Only one holds the trophy. He had the opportunity and he took it.”
He did, though, set a condition for winning the argument outright. “Now the real challenge for him is to keep his number one spot with Alcaraz being healthy and Sinner coming back in January. And if he can manage to beat them, then everybody’s going to shut his mouth.”
Cobolli: fitness was the rarest quality of the season
Cobolli, who lost the Roland Garros final to Zverev in five sets, made a similar point in an interview with Corriere, as quoted by the Daily Express. “If you finish the year at the top, the controversy is zero. It’s been a difficult season for everyone, but not for him,” the Italian said.
Cobolli does not pretend Zverev is the best player on the tour. “Jannik and Carlos are still the strongest in my opinion, but if you’re No. 1, it means you’ve worked hard, that you’ve managed situations well,” he said. “Not getting hurt, at this level, is a great quality. Perhaps, at the moment, the most difficult and desired.” His verdict: “He deserves it.”
That is a subtler defence than Mouratoglou’s. It concedes the quality gap and argues that availability is a skill in its own right. In a season when Alcaraz spent four and a half months out, missing Roland Garros and Wimbledon, and Sinner has not played since July because of a knee problem, it is hard to dismiss.
Toni Nadal: “a little ahead of the rest”
The counter-view comes from Toni Nadal, who spent ten days with Zverev at the Rafa Nadal Academy after the grass-court season. Speaking to the Spanish outlet SPORT, in comments reported by Tennis365, he said: “Carlos and Jannik Sinner are a little ahead of the rest.” He added: “It is clear that, when the first two are injured – as has happened this year, first with Carlos and then with Sinner – the door opens so that other players can benefit from those absences.”
Even so, he was generous about what Zverev has done. He noted that one of the two Grand Slams came with Alcaraz in the draw, and said: “I’m sure next year he will be a player to count on in the big tournaments.”
What the record says
The numbers explain why the debate refuses to die. Zverev won Roland Garros and the US Open, but lost his only 2026 meeting with Alcaraz, in the Australian Open semi-finals after serving for the match, and lost all five meetings with Sinner, taking one set, in the Wimbledon final. On the way to his two majors he beat one top-10 player: Ben Shelton in the US Open final.
Turin offers a partial answer at best. Zverev is in the John McEnroe group with Shelton, Arthur Fils and Jodar, while Alcaraz is in the other group with Daniil Medvedev, Cobolli and Frances Tiafoe, and Sinner is absent. A third ATP Finals title, after 2018 and 2021, would strengthen his hand, but a meeting with Alcaraz could only come in the knockout rounds. For how the event works, see our ATP Finals 2026 explainer, and for the earlier round of this argument, Connors and Federer on whether Zverev is a deserving No. 1.
Mouratoglou and Cobolli are right that the rankings reward what happened, not what might have happened. Toni Nadal is right that the head-to-heads still point the other way. The only thing that settles it is the test Mouratoglou set: beating a healthy Alcaraz and a returning Sinner in 2027.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
