Football • Pundits

Ex-referee Graham Scott says Arteta is the hardest manager to deal with and “gets away with rather too much”

Former Premier League referee Graham Scott says Arteta pushes the touchline limits all the time, and admits officials, himself included, let him. Arteta insists other managers are far worse.

Mikel Arteta has spent the autumn insisting that other managers break the touchline rules far more often than he does. A former Premier League referee has now given the opposite view from the other side of the white line: Graham Scott says Arteta is the hardest manager to deal with, and that officials, himself included, have let him get away with too much.

“He really does push all of the limits”

Scott, who spent a decade refereeing in the Premier League, made the comments to the Athletic, as reported by the Mirror. He began by anticipating the reaction. “I know whatever I say at this point just gets me pelters and it will be ‘well that’s because you hate him’ but it is Arteta. He is the hardest work and he really does push all of the limits all of the time.”

Crucially, Scott did not present it as a character flaw. “I don’t mind that in many ways, he’s trying to get a competitive advantage for his team. That’s fine. It is part of his job, and he’s entitled to push those limits and it is for us to police them.”

The fourth official’s nightmare

His complaint was practical. “But he does make your life extremely difficult. He’s out of his box all the time,” Scott said. He cited Arsenal’s recent match against Everton, in which “every time Everton had the ball anywhere near the touchline on his side, he was joining in the press! His toes were on the touchline and as a fourth official that’s a nightmare.”

He then explained why it so rarely leads to action. “Because if you step forward and do anything about it you’re being pedantic, you’re being petty, but the time you get there the ball’s moved on, it looks like nothing’s going on here. But he does get away with rather too much. The officials do need to be a bit tighter, and I was one of them who let him do that, I’m not going to deny that.”

That admission is the most striking part of his account. It is unusual for a former official to say publicly that the problem is partly one of enforcement, and that he was among those who did not enforce it.

Arteta’s defence: “I am not in the record yet”

Arteta has already set out his side of the argument. He accepts he steps over the line at times, but says some colleagues are far worse and are rarely punished, and that he has been collecting evidence to prove it. “I do have to be careful. They should put sensors there,” he said. “There are managers who have the record in the league, 36 times in 10 minutes [they] leave the touchline – no yellows. I am clipping all of that so I have now a massive storage of images, so if somebody comes to me I can say, ‘I am not in the record yet’. Somebody else has the record so let’s see.”

Jonathan Wilson has already questioned whether that approach is wise, arguing that if it is a deliberate strategy it is a risky one for Arsenal, in our piece on Wilson and Arteta’s dossier.

Who is right?

The two positions are not as far apart as they look. Arteta’s case is relative: others are worse, so singling him out is unfair. Scott’s case is absolute: whatever anyone else does, Arteta is the most persistent, and the officials have allowed it to become normal. Both can be true at once.

Scott’s suggestion also points to the obvious fix. If fourth officials feel petty acting on toes over a line in real time, the answer is either clearer enforcement from the start of a season or, as Arteta himself suggests, technology. Until then, the technical area will remain one of the few places where the rules depend largely on who is standing next to it.

The timing matters too. Arteta led Arsenal to the Premier League title last season, their first in 22 years, and they are again at the top of the conversation this autumn, as Ashley Williams argued when he called it a one-horse race. The more Arsenal win, the more closely every edge they seek will be examined, on the pitch and on the touchline.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!