Football • Pundits

Keane calls Trafford’s Madrid start “smart management” and says there is “not much between” him and Pickford

Roy Keane backed Thomas Tuchel’s decision to start James Trafford against Spain, and the Leeds goalkeeper’s stoppage-time double save sealed a 3-2 win. Tuchel insists England have “no No 1”.

Thomas Tuchel insists England do not have a first-choice goalkeeper. “There’s no No 1,” he said after the 3-2 win over Spain in Madrid. Roy Keane, working for Sky Sports on the night, did not quite go that far, but his verdict on James Trafford’s display points the same way: the gap between the Leeds goalkeeper and Jordan Pickford has all but closed.

Keane: “This is the perfect time”

Keane backed the selection before a ball was kicked. “I think it’s smart management,” he said, speaking on Sky Sports before kick-off. “This is the perfect time for Trafford to come in, against top players, and show what he’s capable of doing.”

For an hour, Trafford had very little to show. Spain had not managed a shot on target when Elliot Anderson was sent off in the 63rd minute, and the 24-year-old’s evening up to that point consisted mostly of goal kicks and short passes out from the back. The red card changed everything. Spain swarmed forward, and the decisive moment came in stoppage time, when Trafford dived to his right to keep out Fermin Lopez and then pushed Mikel Oyarzabal’s follow-up around the post.

Keane was struck by the speed of the second movement rather than the first. “Every time you watch goalkeepers doing drills, it’s that, making the save and then the reaction,” he said. His conclusion on the wider debate was measured but telling: “There’s not much between them.”

Tuchel keeps the door open both ways

Tuchel praised Trafford without crowning him. “He had a brilliant match,” the England manager said, before framing the selection as competition rather than succession. “That’s his job, to close the gap. We want competition in all positions.”

He singled out the late double save – “absolutely brilliant” – but spent just as long on Trafford’s work with the ball, highlighting his composure in the deep build-up as England tried to play through Spain’s press. That matters for a coach whose side built the first hour of this win on pace and directness from the back.

The case for Pickford

The counter-argument is not hard to make. Pickford has been England’s undisputed first choice for the best part of a decade, and his 94 caps leave him behind only Peter Shilton among England goalkeepers. Trafford has five. Pickford also has 372 Premier League appearances to his name.

Only last week, former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson argued that Pickford is still England’s No 1 and the Trafford debate is one for “down the road”. Madrid has arguably brought that road closer.

The club numbers back both men. According to Opta data, Trafford ranks top among Premier League goalkeepers for goals prevented this season, having conceded eight times from shots worth 12.40 expected goals for Leeds. Pickford has a positive return too, conceding 10 from shots worth 11.05. The difference is age and trajectory: Pickford is 32, Trafford eight years younger.

What Keane is really saying

Keane’s line about “smart management” is the more interesting part of his analysis. He is not arguing that Pickford should be dropped; he is crediting Tuchel for testing his alternative in a match that mattered, away to the world champions, rather than in a friendly. It is the same Keane who called England’s first-half display “perfect” at the interval, and who has been harder on individuals in this camp, as he was with Trent Alexander-Arnold after the Croatia game.

England now head into the Nations League quarter-final draw on Friday as group winners, with two-legged ties to come in March. Whoever starts in goal then will tell us whether Tuchel’s “no No 1” is a diplomatic holding position or a genuine shift. On Keane’s reading, it would be no surprise if the answer is Trafford.


Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!