talkSPORT’s Henry Winter expects Michael Carrick to lose his job during the international break. He also argues that the sack would fix very little at Manchester United.
Manchester United have gone nine matches without a win for the first time since 1988, after losing 2-0 at Chelsea. That followed a 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth the weekend before, according to talkSPORT’s report. Carrick is expected to be in the dugout against Roma on Tuesday, with Aston Villa visiting Old Trafford in the last match before the November international break.
Winter: the break is the moment
Speaking on talkSPORT’s Sunday Edition, Winter said the schedule makes a decision likely. “You go into the Roma game. You prepare for that,” he said. “And then he limps on into the Aston Villa game and probably loses his job in the international break.”
His reasoning is practical. “We know what international breaks are like in the rhythm of managers; if they’re going through a difficult time, it gives the club opportunity and time to get someone in,” Winter said. He also pointed to the risk of players travelling to national teams and being asked about their manager. Interviews with the likes of Bruno Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez, he suggested, would produce headlines that are “just a bit too much”.
That is a cold argument, and an unattractive one for anyone who values stability. But it reflects how many clubs actually behave: the break is the least disruptive time to change a head coach.
“Not Michael Carrick’s fault”
What makes Winter’s view more interesting is that he does not think the manager is the main cause. “That squad needs just a huge clear-out,” he said. He went through the afternoon at Chelsea one issue at a time: Carrick started the season needing a left-back and a striker and “was given three midfielders – two of whom probably are not up to it”; it was “not Michael Carrick’s fault that Amad Diallo didn’t put those chances away”; and it was “not Michael Carrick’s fault that Lisandro Martinez behaved the way he did”.
His conclusion: “So look, you can get rid of the coach, but you’re not getting rid of the overall problem.”
It is a coherent position, though it sits oddly next to his own forecast. If the squad is the problem, a change of manager in November looks like a ritual rather than a remedy. Winter appears to accept that, saying the “circus” will simply continue with another manager “until you sort out the ownership”.
Other voices on Carrick
Winter’s verdict is one of several this week. Jamie Carragher said Carrick wants out, while Neville called United’s delay a failure of planning. A day later, Carrick blamed “the moments” at Chelsea and Barney Ronay said he was not even the story. Winter adds a different angle: he expects the club to act regardless.
The counter-view is that a club in a nine-match winless run cannot wait for a perfect squad before acting, and that a new manager changes training, selection and mood faster than a transfer window can. Against that, Winter’s list of individual errors is a fair description of what Carrick cannot control from the touchline.
The next two matches will matter less for what they reveal about Carrick than for what they reveal about the players. If the same errors recur against Roma and Villa, Winter’s second point will be hard to argue with.
Subscribe to Punditfeed on Google News for all the latest updates from the world of sports!
